Approximately 2,000 broadcasters were in Nashville last week for the 39th annual Country Radio Seminar. The event is extremely useful on a lot of fronts — good for networking, good for picking up new business ideas and good for record companies trying to expose their artists to an industry that’s vital to creating stars.Ironically, this year’s gathering came just days before the fifth anniversary of Natalie Maines’ career-deflating statement in London in which she said the Dixie Chicks were “ashamed the president of the United States is from Texas.” Lots of radio stations immediately pulled Chicks songs off the air, saying they were reacting to listeners who threatened to tune them out permanently. That’s a major fear for radio, which is a particularly conservative medium: Stations with no listeners get no ad dollars.
The Chicks pulled a symbolic move just two years ago when they released “Not Ready to Make Nice,” their angry reaction to the public’s kiss-off, on March 10, 2006. Quite ironically, just two days prior (on March 8, 2006), Tim McGraw and Faith Hill had slammed the same president for his administration’s inadequate reaction to Hurricane Katrina.
“If you don’t know what to do,” McGraw said to several radio syndicators, “you shouldn’t be doing it.”
Fans were apparently not outraged, they didn’t threaten to stop listening, and McGraw and Hill went unscathed.
You can parse the two situations a bit: The Chicks made their statement on foreign soil about a war that hadn’t yet started, and their opinion contrasted with that of many Americans. McGraw and Hill were commenting on a disaster that was months in the past, and their views were seemingly shared by a majority.
No punishment was in order for the McGraws.
But none was in order for the Chicks either. Maines’ comment was made to set up their song “Travelin’ Soldier,” a very poignant piece about the tragedy that surrounds war — every war. Take a look at the documentary Shut Up and Sing, and it’s hard to see her statement as anything but an informed opinion that was weirdly turned into a rallying cry.
Radio took a monetarily motivated stance in the aftermath, and it’s still impossible to hear the Chicks in many — if not most — markets. You can’t really blame the broadcasters for protecting their business. But they did play a part in a storyline that is one of the most embarrassing developments in pop culture’s history.