
If one thing surprised me about this year’s CMA nominees, it’s that Tim McGraw didn’t receive a significant nomination — and the Dixie Chicks did. The only nomination McGraw received when the announcements were made Thursday (Aug. 30) was in the musical event category for the assistance he and Kenny Chesney gave to their friend Tracy Lawrence in recording his hit, “Find Out Who Your Friends Are.” The Chicks, on the other hand, are up for vocal group of the year.
My observation about the Chicks is in no way political. I like their music — a lot — but I’m not interested in what Natalie Maines has to say about the war and politics. I should point out, too, that I’m also not interested in what any other celebrity has to say about war and politics — whether it’s Charlie Daniels or Toby Keith or Sean Penn or Tim Robbins or … well … any of them. There are better sources of information and enlightenment, but I certainly defend everyone’s right to freedom of speech.
The surprising thing about the Chicks’ vocal group of the year nomination is that they simply didn’t do much to earn it during the official eligibility period of July 1, 2006 through June 30, 2007. According to the CMA’s official wording, “Singles, albums, music videos and qualifying products for the vocal event must have been first released during the eligibility period.” This doesn’t specifically address the issue of what qualifies for a vocal group nomination, although but you’d think any accomplishments should take place during the same time span. The Dixie Chicks did not release an album during the eligibility period. And if they released a single to country radio, it must not have received much airplay. Their last single to reach Billboard’s country charts, “Not Ready to Make Nice,” was released in March 2006.
As I recall, the Dixie Chicks didn’t even tour after July 1, 2006, but McGraw sure did. His Soul2Soul tours with wife Faith Hill were among the hottest concert tickets in the U.S. during 2006 and 2007. McGraw’s latest album, Let It Go, was released in March and has sold more than 1 million copies. Two of his singles released this year hit the Top 10 — “Last Dollar (Fly Away)” and “I Need You,” the latter a duet with Hill. And surely the CMA voters wouldn’t discriminate against McGraw for stealing the show at this year’s Academy of Country Music Awards show when he performed “If You’re Reading This,” a song he co-wrote with the Warren Brothers. He hadn’t even formally recorded the song when Let It Go was released, but public demand forced McGraw’s management and record label to release the live recording as a single.
The Dixie Chicks did get some airplay on non-country radio stations, so maybe that’s what turned the tide for them with CMA voters. Or maybe it’s just because there aren’t as many vocal groups around, so the competition isn’t quite as severe as it is in most of the other categories. And, let’s face it, against Rascal Flatts and Little Big Town, the Chicks don’t have a snowball’s chance of winning.
Wait! I just figured it out! The Chicks’ nomination obviously stemmed from Shut Up and Sing, the documentary about the uproar in the aftermath of Maines’ infamous comment about George W. Bush. Think about it: Country music is seldom the central theme of a feature film, so this obviously fits within the CMA’s mission to “guide and enhance the development of country music throughout the world.”