What Was Missing From the CMAs?
Did anyone else feel like there was something missing from last night's CMA Awards show? Like a bigger cast of characters, perhaps? I truly adore all the artists who won, but there were just so many people who didn't win, didn't get nominated and, even worse, didn't even go. Where was Dierks Bentley, whose last year was full of Top 10 singles and nonstop tour dates? Where was Phil Vassar, whose Prayer of a Common Man album kicked ass? Why wasn't Ashton Shepherd, the best thing to happen to country music, nominated for anything? Toby Keith wasn't there. I didn't see Tim McGraw or Faith Hill, either. Did he get the snub, or is he too cool for the CMAs now that he's about to host Saturday Night Live? And while I did see Luke Bryan in the audience, I really thought he belonged on stage clutching one of those crystal awards.
©2008 Country Music Television, Inc., a Viacom company. A division of
RedMaZ says:
Pop Country is limited to just a certain few. That’s why musically it the smallest genre in todays Country Music scene. If you’re not making someone money, you’re not recognized. The people you mentioned will never win a cma award.
Lyndsi says:
The main thing that I noticed was that Rascal Flatts did not perform. They are one of the hottest things in country music, won Vocal Group of the year and did not perform???? I understand why Kid Rock was on the show, his song All Summer Long is great and has had major success on Country radio but if it meant Kid Rock or Rascal Flatts I would have rather seen Rascal Flatts. I love Nicole Kidman, Hugh Jackman, and Reese Witherspoon but I almost wished they would have had Tim, Faith, Dolly, Luke, Gretchen give out the awards. I understand Nicole since she is married to Keith and aslo Reese because she is from Nashville and one an Oscar playing June Carter Cash but I just think that when you are talking about Country’s biggest night you should have Country Music Stars giving out the awards. Also no offense to Shania but was that really that huge of a suprise??? I’m glad she’s back and hopefully will be making some new music but I thought it was going to be an artist that would be playing a new song not just giving out an award. Just my opinion.
Katie says:
I agree with Lyndsi. I don’t understand, no matter what the reason, movie stars have to give out awards at the CMAs. This is a night for country music and it’s stars NOT Hollywood. You sure don’t see any country singers handing out Oscars, do you? I especially missed seeing Toby Keith. I think he was a bit peeved because he wasn’t nominated and I don’t blame him. How many hits to you have to have to be recognized???
Connie says:
While I think anyine that cares about Country Music waits for all the shows and awards that appear on TV.. I think
it ABC did awful with broadcasting… The sound was not that great… And commericals was popping up at the wrong time… And it was like the groups singing together or even solo…. was not sure of sound like they were looking at each other…because alot of the beginnings of songs sounded off…. And for us that have a nice HDTV and nice surround sound….it wasn’t that great….. Love CMA’s and loved that Kid Rock was there….disappointed in boardcast by ABC…. Nascar use to have same problems…and it I am not mistaken the same thing happen last year and everybody was talking about it……
Deb says:
I loved the CMAs. Enjoyed them so much. I thought Carrie and Brad did a great job hosting. Loved seeing so many performances. Awesome night of great country music!!
MiaT says:
I too thought there was just something missing. I must say I really, really missed seeing Tim & Faith. ( Sorry all you McGraw haters). It just didn’t seem right that they were not even there. I kept thinking..wow I wonder if Tim & Faith are cuddled up on the couch like me watching this show. Did they also notice how bad the sound quality was? Oh well, plenty of more award shows ahead!
ashley says:
it was missing everything it did not impress me this year gretchen wilson didnt perform wasnt nominated tim mcgraw faith hill and ashton sheperd. redmaz i have to disagree with you when you said they will never win a cma they could one day you never know
Kellianne says:
Personally, alot of performers that they added in my opinion should’ve have been added. The Eagles? I mean seriously? I’ve only seen 2 videos on CMT of them, unlike some that may have never performed have at least 4-5!
My biggest disappointment being a fan was Little Big Town, they were up for Group and obviously it would’ve gone to Rascal Flatts though I think someone else should win it! Greedy for winning in 6 years in a row now? I think so. Pass the title down, share a little. Don’t get me wrong though they are fantasic people in country music however give others a change won’t ya? It also surprized me because Life In A Northern Town didn’t win, it was a pretty big event at the CMA’s last year alot enjoyed it.
Kim says:
Yeah, this year was predictable. Liked Kid Rock the best, but I don’t think he’s a country star. What is with the sound? So sick of the usual crowd only getting the awards. Do these people know where the bodies are buried or something?
and why, oh why is Carrie Underwood the only Female artist who can sing anymore? and no one say that’s it because she had the biggest tour, best album, blah blah blah. Rascal Flatts had a huger tour, a great selling album, a greatest hits album, plenty of MUSICALLY related exposure, and they didn’t get even a nomination for entertainer of the year. the reason the CMA’s gave was the it wasn’t just about numbers this year. So if we can justify stiffing RF of at least a nomination (if not the actual award) they clearly deserved, why doesn’t the same logic apply to the Female vocalist award?
I think leaving RF out and Sugarland in was strictly about getting a woman in the category; there was too much bitching about only the men ever get it. Actually giving it to sugarland was to obvious of a political move, but the nom was enough to get the critics off their backs. That was political to the core, and if I were RF i’d be way insulted. I’d almost go Toby Keith and start boycotting. Just me.
katie says:
Maybe they should let people like Kid Rock and The Eagles get nominated for their own genre where they belong and they’d be able to nominate people who are actually country, like Luke Bryan and Dierks Bentley.
Nana says:
I don’t believe these awards are given on a who’s turn it is. I also believe some of the ones you mentioned was not there because they were not nominated and that is a shame they should be there to support the ones there were. Toby is a different story–I don’t blame him.
And for the last time–there was nothing wrong with the sound–same ones sound bad everytime and always their fans say something was wrong with the sound.
taylor fan says:
wha was missing was that taylor should took home that award last night. carrie get thangs handed to her to much its time someone that has a great year last year and this year get it taylor swift rules!!!!
Steph says:
sounds like no one was happy this year…maybe that means something…what could it be….?
Carol says:
I sure missed Sara Evans along with many others.
steve says:
This is country musics night and Hollywood is nice, but the show was in Nashville. Why not get George Jones or Terri Clark, Connie Smith and Marty to present the awards. They might not have a hit now but they certainly paved the way.The resources that must have been unbelievable, to many to name who could’ve given awards out. Look at the reception Shania got. I think the artists would have liked it, and so would the fans
diane says:
I think Carrie does an outstanding job..winner or not..no way can Taylor sing live…..but it would have been nice to hear from the true powerhouses of country music..Sarah,Martina,Reba,LeAnn,Garth,Trisha,I could go on and on….
Brenda Allison says:
I live in S.C. and my sister lives in N.C.. I called her last night and asked were we watching a rock awards show?????? What is going on with the new country? Every
entertainer seems to go for the money and forget the roots in which we all came from. Ever who books the presenters, should step back and take a look at the past shows for 20 years, which I have not missed a one, and look at today’s. Where were some of the standards? Are they being looked over now because they are not making you as rich any more? As for the entertainers. I couldn’t half hear the voices because the music was so loud and when I could hear their voices it was like they were screaming !!! I always belive in moving with the times, but this is ridiculous !!!! That was not country music I heard. One of the worst Country Awards Show I have watched in years. Good country music is what the every day person can identify with and that certainly was not…. If it was Country Rock, then set up a catagory for that, otherwise fans are going to stop going to see Country Entertainers and then the money will start dropping and maybe then it will open some eyes !!! Wake up country entertainers and be what you claim to be, “Country Music Entertainers”!!!
Stacey says:
I will start by saying that I love country music, but I do not limit myself to that type of music. I am a huge fan of music, that being said I adore Tim and Faith and Toby and Dierks. To me it is a slap in the face when you look at the past couple of years Tim and Faith have had with the what top selling country tour one hundred twenty three million plus albums. It’s like if you step outside the boundry of country music you are left out. I don’t understand it. The only reason I watched the show was to see Keith Urban, Sugarland, Brad Paisley, but it sorrows me to see so many great artists left out of what have should have been a great showing of the true meaning of the country community. Shame on the politics of the CMA’S
CT country girl says:
SOOOOO Glad you wrote this blog somebody had to!!! There are SO many artists to choose from and there were so many left out entirely. I understand there can only be the best of the best nominated but I think it’s pretty sad not to recognize the artists like Dierks, Tim, Luke, Blake or Toby!!! These are the artists that are continuing to grow and shine and have had an enormous amount of credibility in 08!!! Also the sound WAS HORRIBLE ugh….everyone that performed sounded off in one way or another!!! I agree though Brad and Carrie did a great job in hosting.
Thanks again for the blog you said what we were all thinking!!!
Katie says:
Taylor Swift is good, I like her a lot. But seriously, her vocals are nothing compared to Carrie Underwood.
Sherry says:
Carrie and Brad did an excellent job, singing and hosting. They both truly earned their trophies. I think they were both standouts in their catagories. I was sorry Trace did not take home an award. He is so deserving. I did miss RF performing. Country music is growing and with that comes growing pains. There is no way to please everyone. I am sure we will see more of Tim, Faith, Dierks, Sarah, and it looks like Shaniah. Kenney seemed very glad to see her!
jill says:
To the person that posted about Rascal Flatts winning for the 6th year in a row and calling them greedy. Are you kidding me!?? These guys work their tails off! They played to 1.2 million fans, have huge album sales, and mostly HUGE hearts. They are constantly giving back to the community. They have raised 3 million for Vanderbilt in the last 3 years, and they were honored with the Shining Star award for the Make-A-Wish foundation. Plus they are amazing to their fans!! They are the most humble and down to earth guys ever. They really don’t take anything for granted and work their hardest to make their live shows and their music the best for their fans. For you to say they don’t deserve Vocal Group of the year is just ignorant!! They should of been nominated for Entertainer of the Year and won. You don’t see Kenny playing on the road all year, just the summer and you don’t see him giving back to community like RF.. He cares more about going and sitting on a island somewhere.
Jeffrey says:
I would have liked to see Blake Shelton or Luke Bryan perform their new songs!!
Erin says:
Rascal Flatts def. shouldve performed and i love carrie underwood to death and her performance was amazing but mabe next time she could do more then just stay in one spot…and i think they need to change it up a little bit with the winners the same people win every year and i think that all the country people should be recognized because they are all pretty awesome!
Brittany says:
Congrats to Rascal Flatts on another HIGHLY deserved “Vocal Group of the Year” award. You guys are truly amazing performers and people. Not only does your music touch millions of peoples hearts… but so does your cosistent charity work. You guys actually have true talent. Pure, amazing voices and incredible istrument playing. You guys are humble, gracious, respectful men and you don’t take advantage of your fame. You continually make hit singles and change peoples lives with your spectacular music.
Rascal Flatts have had one of the top selling tours of 2007/2008 and countless other top tours. They have sold MILLIONS of albums and had a jillion hit singles. They put on AMAZING shows, that take fan’s breaths away. And they don’t even get a nomination for “Entertainer of the Year.” Are you fricken kidding me??? CMA’s, are you absolutely crazy!!??? You put Sugarland in just cuz they walked across the crowd in big bubble balls at the CMA Music Fest. And you just want to be able to put a women in that category to get people off your back because its a male dominated category. Rascal Flatts deserve more than just a nomination, although some would be content with that. They should have won this award countless times. Rascal Flatts are true entertainers, who love to share their msuic and inspire others. They deserve to be the “Entertianer of the Year.” Open your eyes and ears CMA’s!!! Seriously.
Dee says:
OK, seriously, what was missing was a person who knew how to run sound for live performances! Over half of the performers you could hardly hear over their bands. I mean when you can’t hear Martina McBride, someone isn’t doing their job right!
Nana says:
This is to Erin–Really come on now–with a song like Just A Dream–what would you want Carrie to do–run and jump all over the stage?? Makes no sense. Carrie did not need to change anything about her performance.
And to who ever said they would have liked to see Blake perform on the show–so would I– I can think of 2 spots that should have gone to someone else–anyone else!!
fwoi@ejhf.com says:
Great Show— WHere was LeAnn Rimes????????????????
LeeLand says:
Where was Jimmy Wayne whose album cd “Do You Believe Me Now” is one of the best albums I’ve ever heard? Every song on it is a winner. He is my favorite country singer.
LeeLand says:
I forgot to say, that I know that Jimmy Wayne presented an award and I appreciated that because I got to see him, but he should have been performing and receiving an award as far as I’m concerned.
King says:
I think what was missing was.. good music and good songs.
Samantha says:
I think everyone did a great job last night. But I am upset that Toby Keith, Dierks Bentley, Tim Mcgraw, and Faith Hill don’t get nominated anymore. I am sorry Alison Krauss did not deserve at all to be nominated nor win Musical Event of the Year. Life in the Northern Town should have had won it. Come on now!!! What are the CMA people thinking. I miss the Rascal Flatts and Little Big Town, they both didn’t perform. I always liked the ACM awards and the CMT awards better. ohwell, I enjoyed the show still=]
Ken says:
George Strait and Brad Paisley are the only true country music artists among the award winners. Rascal Flatts, Carrie Underwood and Sugarland are not country music artists. Never have been, never will be.
These awards insult the greats in country music. Let’s get back to the real thing.
tallhat says:
The most interesting part was seeing who was left out. All of the aforementioned plus Big & Rich!
Katya says:
I have to agree with the majority here. I’m an “old-timer”, been in love with country music all the way back to the Eddie Arnold, Lynn Anderson, Johnny and June, Patsy, you get the idea, days. And, I’d walk barefoot and on fire through broken glass to get to a King George concert. That said, there are so many “true” country artists out and about today that I think are terrific, like Craig Morgan and the Zac Brown Band, to mention only a microcosm… where were they? (And a personal fave, Keni Thomas.) Music is representative of the current culture but why send the heart-and-soul to deep background? That was one thing that I always so appreciated about CM… the forerunners were never forgotten. At least George and Alan got the spotlight.
I do really like Taylor and Carrie, though… two completely different but tremendously talented voices. Brad and Keith… oh, be still my old heart! ;)
The audio technical problems were rather annoying in the first half, though. You could tell the performers were having a big problem with it, too. We initially thought it was our TV, had it cranked up to a 42 on the volume! Expect much better from a major network like ABC.
Overall, I’d give this year’s show a 4.5 out 5. Here’s hoping next year’s is better. Oh, yeah, hot diggity dawg… Shania, girl, it’s time to get back into the studio! One last… I live in Augusta, GA… major Congrats to Lady A! We love ‘em!
lorendasue says:
The broadcast was BORING. I almost went to bed before the end. I understand why non-country artist folk are brought in for presenting, as it is hoped that they will bring in a bigger audience. Can’t blame ABC for doing what it thinks it needs to do to get as big an audience as possible. At least these days they bring in presenters who know at least a little bit about the country music artists. I’m certain that the general thinking by the corporate heads at ABC is that country music alone can’t draw as big an audience as they need for the night. As for the performances, there were too many which were songs I’ve heard plenty of and have seen performed on TV before - Trace Adkins for example. It was nice to see Brad Paisley and Keith Urban perform together for the first time and I enjoyed the fun aspect of Kid Rock’s performance. For the most part, however, the whole thing was just too ho-hum. And then there’s that thing about the way it sounds on my TV - a problem which has been around for the CMA and ACM for a few years now. I’ve come to watch such shows more for the fashion (what was with all the black this year?) and the way folks interact. Actually enjoyed the red carpet moments I watched better than the show.
Shotgun says:
This post was really surprising (since it came from Alison) but also delightful!
Quick message to the “upper” folks in Nashville (or wherever)that are trying to systematically disenfranchise an entire culture:
You forgot the cardinal rule of social change. The frogs WILL jump out of the boiling pot if you turn up the heat too quickly! Don’t forget that guys…you’re moving a little too fast for country folk.
To you proud rural / agrarian / cowboy type Americans (be you in the land you love literally or only there in your heart): Consider the changing times as a benefit to us (specifically the new technology) and remember the words of a very wise man…
“It’s alright, to be little bitty…”
Janel says:
Okay…first of all I have been watching these awards for years…love them…but this year something was lacking…first of all, there was not excitement…just kind of all bla…I think Carrie needs to stick to singing first of all…she is uber talented and can rock that voice…i’m sorry but no talent in acting or ‘hosting’…the sound issues left something else to be desired…again…this is a huge event, why wasn’t it taken care of with the first oopsies…
Next, to the person who said that Rascal Flatts should hand the crown down to the next generataion…what do you want them to do…leave the industry??? Do you think they make the music to win the award…they have no control over who wins or whose nominated…they just make their music…if they DID have any power you can be darn sure they would have won that Entertainer of the Year award considering the tickets and CD’s they’ve sold this year…that is nuts…did anyone complain with Brooks and Dun won their award ten million years in a row…no…because they earned it and they deserved it…and you cannot honestly tell me that you think anyone else in that category ‘earned it’ or ‘deserved’ it more than the flatts…look at their numbers for pete’s sake…do the other nominations even headline a show in sold out arenas…the snub of Rascal Flatts for EOTY was obvious, and absolutely ludacrist…I’m not saying that Lady A or LBT aren’t talented…I LOVE THEIR MUSIC…but to say that the flatts are being greedy is crazy…talk to me in 8 years when Lady A and LBT is still around and then we can talk winning an award again…
Aside from them there were other OBVIOUS exclusions from McGraw and Hill, to Keith and MANY OTHERS! This was just a poor awards show in my opinion…I hope that in a few monts the ACM’s can get some things straightened out and give us a show we can actually enjoy….
vp says:
C’mon guys, everyone would of liked to of seen their fav atrist there, or perform or win. The fact is the show has agreements with the network to get the ratings and the networks know who the rating getters are and that is the top selling most popular artist. Yes Rascal Flatts was overlooked to perform and for ETOTY, Tim over looked, both had amazing years.
As for artists being greedy or changing up who wins if you watched the show right to the end it explained the voting process and it is on their site, 6000 people vote and there were two rounds of voting, one that has a list of like let’s say for MVOTY the top 30 artist the people who pay to belong to the association pick their top 5, from there all the votes are tallied and they get their top five. Then send out another final ballot which is for who should win the award.
This is an award given to them by their peers not the fans and they don’t give them to themselves. the 6000 voter’s think that these are the people that best represented country music this year.
So someone could win for 8 years in a row and that would be because their peers put them there, if everyon has such a problen with the selection process, then pay the like $5000 a year dues and become a membe and you will have your vote counted.
These artist give it their all for who, us, to please who, us the fans. They work very hard all of them in differnt ways and they and their music should be appreciated, not hacked on all the time.
Tracy says:
The only thing I have to say is Rascal Flatts should have performed!!! They were snubbed the ETOY nomination and WHY who knows. I am glad that they won Vocal Group of the year they deserved it!! And no they are not being greedy about it either. They work there butts off all year long touring and selling out venues across the country.
Ryan says:
Here’s my problem with the CMA Awards: With the exception of New Artist (formerly known as the “Horizon Award”), Musical Event, Single of the Year and Musician of the Year, the list of this year’s winners is identical to last year!
Entertainer-Kenny, Male Vocalist-Brad, Female-Carrie, Duo-Sugarland, Group-Flatts, Album-George Strait, Song-George Strait.
*Yawn*
Now, I’m not saying that some of them weren’t deserving to win, but c’mon! I kept hoping for a surprise…but it never materialized.
Well, unless you count Shania’s cleavage.
Shelly says:
The CMA’s were not great this year nor have they been over the last couple of years. Let’s face it, the CMA’s is the industry scratching another’s back…it is NOT fan based voting! It is just another night for the record companies to promote their “acts”.
It always nice to see the live performances but I agree, let’s not forget some of the other great performers! That is what is wrong with country music & radio… it is a select few and they are over exposed (case in point - Taylor Swift - love her music but becoming over-exposed!). That is why they die out so fast and new come on board. Lets learn to give equal time to each so they have staying power and we, as country music fans, get a better selection of music from acts that are not over exposed and will have longevity.
Susan Rabalais says:
I agree with all of you, especially when it comes to Tim and Faith not being nominated for anything. I am not certain what is going on regarding that. In 2007, Tim and Faith had one of the largest grossing tours and they were not nominated then either. Tim’s albums are the best! Also why didn’t Blake Shelton sing his hit ” Home”. He is an awesome singer, where were Montgomery Gentry, I don’t think they were even nominated. I give up trying to understand, I did watch it though, it is like one big concert, but this show along with ACM’s needs to be re done.
Kelli says:
I don’t believe Tim or Faith has has any good songs for a couple of years. Their tours may been high grossing, only due to High Ticket Prices. Kenny beat them the last two years in concert gross. Kenny charges less for tickets. By the way, all these acts better watch their steps these days. the economy will come back to haunt them all.I enjoyed The Cma’s this year, especially Brad Paisley and Keith Urban.
cj says:
It is ironic that all of you seem to have all the answers. I am sure The CMA’s board would love for it to be that easy. It does not matter what they do someone will not be happy. The world seems to be very nagative. It is refreshing when some says something good about someone.
ROSEBUD says:
I didn’t get a chance to read any responses but for me I just felt the “star factor” was missing. It was pretty boring for the most part. There were a few good moments but not many. I just felt the huge stars like Tim and Faith, Sara Evens, LeeAnn Rimes, Dierks, Blake, Toby, (oh lord the list could go on and on) were left out. I like some of the youngins but to me they just aren’t there yet. They just don’t have the star power to carry a show like that on there own. I’m sorry but TS looked like she belonged on the Disney Channel. Just my opinion!
Oh I forgot Montgomery Gentry I love those guys!!!!
Beak says:
I would love to see the “CMA” awards get back to country and less Hollywood. Taylor Swift is as far from country as they come. Her production of Romeo & Juliet did not belong on the CMAs. What happened to real country music? What ever happened to George Jones, Bill Anderson, Connie Smith, Jean Sheppard and so many ofther “real” country music singers. These are the people who paved the way for the so called country singers we have now. This show anymore is nothing more than a rock show and to see who has the tightest clothes that show the most skin! Come on CMA try remember what real country is all about.
Kevin says:
I agree that Blake Shelton should have got to perform. But that is my only comment about somebody being left out. Sure there are always going to be peoply who some wish would have performed, been nominated, or won an award, but still you cant really say that the ones that did make it onstage were not deserving of being there. They’ve got 3 hours for the show, and they squeeze in as much as they can.
As far as who wins the awards..be very careful what you wish for. Fan voting is NOT the way to go. Several years ago it might have been a good idea, but not now. If the CMAs were fan voted, Taylor Swift would have won single, song, female vocalist, video, album, and entertainer. That is because of the way the voting would have been done. If fans got to vote it would be done online. Taylor has built her career in large part online. All of her myspace “friends” vote 20 million times a day. So im pretty sure that the awards would get so much more boring and predictable if they changed the way they vote.
Jason says:
The good days of country music have gone. The Judds, Alabama, Dixie Chicks, Clint Black Randy Travis, Dwight Yoakum. The only Great left one is George Straight.
A says:
i enjoy watching the cma’s…but i too was a little disappointed with the same people winning year after year…i would have also loved to see dierks, sara, billy currington, blake shelton, tim and faith. its sad that not everyone could come to the awards, as it is truly a time to appreciate this genre of music.
i enjoy taylor swift, but think feel that she is trying to break into the pop music scene.
i really think that country fans are the most loyal and true fans, and we would just like to see some variety in both performances and awards. i am not judging anyone who won this year as they deserved it, but lets give some others a chance a winning…i feel if you have won before you shouldn’t be able to win two consecutive years
but this is just my opinion so i don’t expect anything to change because of it
RedMaZ says:
The AMA Honors and Awards are fan/member voted, and I seen nothing boring or predictable about them, did you? Granted Mainstream Pop Culture is a completely different story, but it can be done with success.
Renee says:
I thought the CMA’s were ok, I give it a B-. Sugarland upsestting B&D was a shock, but where were the rest of the surprises? Where was Dierks? Not even a performance? Come on. That’s ridiculus. No Luke Bryan performance? No Ashton? And I’m sorry, but Keith Urban totally deserved an award last night. All Reba gets is to accompany B&D? Where was Trisha? Blake Shelton? There were so many great artists that weren’t featured, it’s a shame.
Leah says:
I missed Rascal Flatts! They are always there. I also missed Sara Evans, Blake Shelton (who was in the crowd only), Dierks Bentley…if they don’t sing, they at least present. It was just wierd.
RedMaZ says:
Renee, this is a Pop country awards show. Only the top monet makers appear. This is a popularity contest. The people you listed are not making enough money to perform.
Jason you seem to be somewhat out of touch with todays music scene. The Judds of course are no longer, but Wynonna Judd is still making music, same with Alabama, but the lead singer, and guitar player are stil making music, as is Clint Black, Randy Travis, and Dwight Yoakam.
Leah says:
And by the way….fashion sense was out the window!!! Everyone looked great on the red carpet, but I think they got a bit confused on stage….Kelly Pickler..Martina….
Kim says:
The person missing from the CMAs for me was Dierks Bentley. This man works his tail off touring most of the year, he has had several number #1 songs, has his fastest rising single of his career right now with “Feel That Fire”, writes all of his music and is absolutely amazing to his fans. Not to mention, his music has a stronger element of country to it than some of the artists. I just don’t understand why he won the Horizon Award several years ago, but hasn’t been nominated since. Every cd sells better than the last and he puts on an incredible live show. CMA and ACMs are so political. As much as I love Jason Aldean and Rodney Atkins, how can they be considered new artists? How about Luke Bryan or Darius Rucker? Both of which have amazing cds. And if anyone has seen Luke live, he has the “star” quality. His shows are energetic and great. Just a little frustrated with the same people over and over.
Cricket on Froggy 104 says:
Those of you who keep commenting about the sound, go back and read the blogs from the past couple of days. There was a major power outage in downtown Nashville Wednesday, which means most (if not all) of the artists probably didn’t get a proper sound check. Although Carrie did sound fantastic…it’s kind of like the AMA show a couple of years ago when everyone sounded flat until Lionel Richie came out and gave a flawless performance, which kinda told everybody that the problem AIN’T with the monitors, it’s with what’s going into the microphones.
Kevin says:
I was talking about the CMA Awards, which is what the blog is about. Im not concerned with the AMAs
RedMaZ says:
My reference was to awards being fan voted.
Gladys says:
I am recent country music fan so I haven’t watched a lot of award shows. I did watch the past two years. I have read most of the comments and there is kind of an undertone going on. I mean how many of you in here really feel that the awards are rigged.
I mean how do the artists get picked for the awards? If it is through hard work, how many songs the release successfully through the year and things like that then the people who win every year win because they meet all of the criteria. Unless there is the notion that the industry has some corruption going on.
Anyway as for me I enjoyed the awards, all of the people that I saw there have gone out of their way to make themselves visible. I mean they are on the radio, tv, magazines, newspapers, touring etc.
If other artists want to win, get competitive. Take the Kenny risk and tour in stadiums, Rascal Flatts the youth, Carrie the heart and soul of your fans, and Taylor all those young children in school who see their dream just might come true. I could think of one for Bard, but you all get my point.
Matt says:
What the hell has happened to country music? Could Kenny Chesney be anymore awkward when he gives a speech? Is Trace Adkins every gonna win an award? Would it kill somebody to have a little steel guitar or fiddle in their music nowadays? What was going through Alan Jackson’s mind while kid rock was singing? Is anybody gonna come along and make traditional country popular again like Randy Travis did in the 80’s? Did they really use the term “legend” in the teaser about Shania Twain being there? These were all questions going through my mind wednesday night.
RedMaZ says:
There is plenty of Steel Guitar and fiddle in todays country music. In many ways Country Music is better than ever. Are you only listening to Pop Country?
Kevin says:
There is still fiddle and steel guitar in all kinds of country music.
Amy says:
Brad was a great host! Carrie was 2 stiff & she couldn’t say great job to someone after a performance or congrats-way 2 go-after someone winning. She could only read what was on the telepromter.cma’s need more country music singers & presenters. Too many great ones missing.What I would of loved to seen since it was on abc was Julianne Hough & Cody Lindley tango out to the podium to present an award.
bkb says:
martina had a great song and i agree that the sound was bad. usually you can understand every word of a martina song and this year it just didn’t happen, also last year was a little off too, get it together so the artist can be heard at their best.
Melissa says:
Eric Church, Gary Allan, Montgomery Gentry… they never get the recognition they deserve. =/
Always Right says:
Cricket on Froggy 104 said:
“Those of you who keep commenting about the sound, go back and read the blogs from the past couple of days. There was a major power outage in downtown Nashville Wednesday, which means most (if not all) of the artists probably didn’t get a proper sound check. Although Carrie did sound fantastic…it’s kind of like the AMA show a couple of years ago when everyone sounded flat until Lionel Richie came out and gave a flawless performance, which kinda told everybody that the problem AIN’T with the monitors, it’s with what’s going into the microphones.”
Funny, but there wasn’t a power outage last year or the year before yet it sounded the same.
Let’s face it. 98% of pop country artists can’t sing. They are merely the result of studio magic.
MindyM says:
I agree with almost all of the comments here. Too many good Country stars missing. Everything is way too political. Personally, Toby Keith not being there was such a disappointment He’s toured all this year, has had 7 #1 albums on the country charts - 2 in the last year and a half, and he NEVER gets the recognition he deserves. He is “MY DADDY” and I won’t watch the CMAs again unless he’s nominated and performs.
Cricket on Froggy 104 says:
Thanks, Always Right, for validating the second half of my post. It looks like we agree.
Kevin says:
Always Right, I dont think you are accurate with your percentage of pop country artists that cant sing. I have seen every artist that performed on the CMA Awards, and many more that didnt. In all of the concerts I have been to, the artists have sounded great. The sound at awards shows is never very good. The power outtage in Nashville on Wednesday probably didnt help matters any either. When an artists is playing a show of their own, they have time to get the sound set up specifically for their performance and their performance only. They have people who work their sound every single night and know what to expect and what to look for. At an awards show, you have MANY artists performing in a small amount of time. Im not a sound expert, but I bet it is no small task to get sound exactly right for that many different singers and bands in such a short amount of time. These people can sing or they wouldnt be there.
shiloh says:
I was MOST disappointed that Ashton Shepherd was missing entirely from the CMA’s. I find it extremely ridiculous that she wasn’t included. She is more country than ANY of the pop/country wannabe artists out today. For pete’s sake (SHE WROTE HER ENTIRE ALBUM…minus one song that her brother-in-law wrote) I wish she could have performed instead of the horrific ear sores that Kelli Pickler and Taylor Swift performed. You could hear them BOTH running out of steam towards the end of their performances. Gosh it just erks me like no other that traditional country artists have such a hard time breaking through because of all the pop crap that supposed country artist put out and radio plays!!! Don’t get me wrong, i do like SOME of the stuff that pickler and swift do, but really that’s NOT country music. Come on CMA’s put on a show that really represents country music!!!!!!!!
RedMaZ says:
You answered your own questions/concerns. This is a Pop Country event. “Traditional” country will never make it back into Mainstream Pop Country. That’s what we have Americana/Roots music for. There’s plenty of “traditional” country represented there. Follow the the genre and you’ll find the music.
Z says:
Frankly, I couldn’t watch the whole show. I greatly disliked Carrie Underwood as a host. She has no idea how to improve. And how predictable was it when she sang right before the female vocalist award and then won? I was hoping for a little Josh Turner. He has great music. No one can tell me otherwise…I completely think these awards are rigged. JMO!!!
RedMaZ says:
“real country music” doesn’t sell. The only people that listen to Pop Counry are FOR the reasons you gave. Same songs, same artists over and over again. That’s part of the definition of Pop music. Follow the genre and you’ll find the music.
Kevin says:
Real country music does sell. Alan Jackson, George Strait, Blake Shelton, Miranda Lambert. There is 4 examples of real country that sells. I listen to some major radio because I like some of the songs they play…not because they play the same artists over and over again.
RedMaZ says:
That’s you opinion it’s “real country music”, but the fact is, it’s still Pop Country. That’s the only place they’re recognized.
Anonymous says:
RedMaZ you need to calm down. We all realize that you are the foremost authority and that we are never going to have the last word. Yes we understand that everything is screwed up in this genre and that nothing in country music is going to be the same again. I’m sure they had this argument when they switched from calling everything “Country and Western” to just “Country” music as well. It will be alright. And yes, it sucks that the people most of us like never get recognized on awards shows when they work as hard if not harder than all the ones that win the awards. But it will all be ok. <<<>>>> Be happy!
RedMaZ says:
Well, I’m certainly calm. What gave you the impression I wasn’t? And I’m certainly not the foremost authority, but I do know basic music fundamentals. I know the difference between Pop music and Roots music, and I accept each for what they represent. Doesn’t bother me a bit. Actually there is still Country and Western music. There are some great Western Swing artists and bands out there. I listen to many styles and genres of music. That always makes me happy!
rebel yell says:
Im One Budwiser than I was a minute ago…
Kevin says:
Yes, it is my opinion that the artists I named are real country music….just like it is your opinion that they are not real country. Your opinion has no more value than mine does.
RedMaZ says:
I never said they are not “real country”. I said they were Pop Country, and that’s a fact.
Anonymous says:
Snaps for you RedMaZ. I’m glad you have enlightened us with your music wisdom! Just because you are so wise, doesn’t mean that you need to impart that wisdom on every single blogger. In this day and age, there are no basic music fundamentals as you stated….its like art, everybody can interpret it however they want to. Please don’t correct us everytime we interpret music in our own ways. We love what we love and I actually enjoyed the CMA’s no matter what kind of music it featured.
Anonymous says:
Go Kevin!!!!
luvncountry says:
Here we go again…
RedMaZ says:
Yes indeed, here we go again. Are you trying to tell me ther is no Pop Country? No Roots Country? No Mainstream Music? No Americana Music? THAT is basic music fundamentals. Who people like or don’t like is something entirely different.
Anonymous says:
OK, whatever. Like I said before I am not the foremost authority. Excuse me.
Kevin says:
RedMaZ, you said, “real country doesnt sell.” The artists I named SELL. So, yes you did say that they were not real country. Just not in those exact words. And thats a FACT!
Ham says:
pffft Too many people with too many opinions that do not alter a darn thing in Nashville and how the music will get marketed.
JC says:
OMG… I am sick of the CMA’s its a political nightmare where was Sara Evans, Faith, Tim, Toby, Bientley??? Come on Faith Hill and Tim McGraw had the highest grossing Country tour of all time last year and not even a nomination…..how is that right? like them or not the CMA’s should recognize people when they are successful especially when they are bringing fans by the millionns to the genre. The CMA’s are out of touch!!!! no wonder the neilson ratings have plumited the last 2 years.
black cat says:
DIERKS and his BAND rock!!!
WE WANT DIERKS AND HIS BAND ON THE CMA’S!!!!
Kevin says:
I dont think they have forgotten about Dierks. He will be back. He is getting ready to release his new album, so that should get him some nominations and a performance next year.
Candygirl says:
I just want to say that in my opinion Rascal Flatts should of, w/out a shadow of a doubt won ETOTY award. And it listed in our local newspaper the other night the top 10 grossing tours of the yr. Only 1 country act made it…can you guess who? Rascal Flatts was #3! They go way beyond their great music w/all of the charitable work that they do. I know that doesn’t play a part getting an award, but these guy’s are super talented w/hearts of gold!
Leah says:
Yes, I totally agree with you Candygirl!!!!
kaylyn arconti says:
When I watch both the cma awards and the 2008 red carpet show I was so filled of sadness when they didn’t interview dierks bentley on the red carpet.
Holly says:
My two most favorite girl singers were not there, Alison Krauss and LeAnn Rimes that is. Alison should have been lined up to sing at least since she was in there for the Female Artist of the Year award and was given the Musical Event of the Year award! (smiles)
My most favorite part of the show was getting to see my most favorite male singer up there. I love James Otto so much!!! (smiles)
God bless you and him and Alison and LeAnn always!!!
Holly in East Tennessee
JoM says:
yep seems to me they don’t mix up the award show at all.
Why not invite other artists to perform… maybe ones who aren’t nominated as well. Mainstream country isn’t all there is..and frankly the awards are boring.
CMA member says:
What was missing? The new artist award for Rodney Atkins, Kellie Pickler, and Jason Aldean when they were snubbed for their 2nd and final chance of winning new artist. Many CMA members made them wait a year then snubbed them by handing the award to a group that is good but new and hasn’t done much yet. They should have waited for next year like Rodney, Kellie, Jason and others had to before. Shame on you voters who overlooked these 3 great talents twice!
luvncountry says:
I’m with you CMA member. I like Lady A. but THEIR chance should have come NEXT year, not this one. I wanted Kellie to win, but the 2 guys are good too.
Shandra says:
I want to say this:
If you can’t do it live, don’t do it at all. Replicate your live sound in the studio, don’t mess around with electronic enhancements. I was very disappointed that some artists who performed and sounded nothing like their records won awards! If you can’t be true to your sound, don’t perform because it makes the whole industry look bad.
Kim says:
I agree Shandra. Why the producers of country records want to use vocal alteration and enhancements is beyond me. I’ve heard some artists sing great live and when I listen to their albums it’s a disappointment to hear auto tune and other vocal effects some producer used like they do on pop records. Country artists don’t need it and fans and reviewers don’t like it. Stop making the mistake of overproducing albums and stick to live sound like Sugarland does. Keep it real, keep it country.
Billy says:
I can’t wait for the Zac Brown Band to perform on one of these award shows sometime soon. I agree with all the posts about so many great musicians not being there and how disappointing it is to see Kellie Pickler and Taylor Swift perform instead of people like Montgomery Gentry, Luke Bryan, and Ashton Shepherd. Swift might as well start lip syncing because she cannot sing live. I realize that she is a force in the industry with her strong fan base and will remain at the top of the charts because of all the kids that follow her but she has a terrible voice and only sounds good on her album because of all the studio tricks.
Katie says:
This year’s show made me think of how much I really, really miss 90s Country Music. It was…perfect. I miss that crowd.
aussietomt says:
Brother, I watched the show last Saturday Night, Australian Time, and thought it could only get better after last years disaster. WRONG AGAIN.
Whoever put that excuse for country on as a CMA awards show must have been the wrong bundle of envelopes before the rock concert started.
What a disaster the brave wife and mother had to listen to as a tribute to those fallen. Where does something bashed out like Carrie Underwood gave us, have anything to do with the thoughtful words of service and sacrifice, hopefully expressed with dignity.
George Strait now takes the easiest song off his latest album to do live and even Alan Jackson does not appeasr to be allowed to present better selections than those he now offers.
PLEASE VINCE get back to work and write and sing for us some real country. Putting on a few pounds too I noticed old mate.
Millions of US citizens can’t be wrong (can they?) when Kenny Chesney is up for five big ones next year. He would be better placed on a prawn trawler in the ocean above Australia after what he dished up again. Country? What a sham!!! Next year he will offer a rewrite of Blue Hawaii I am sure.
I well realise the older generation has passed by but that is no excuse for the lack of word content in todays offerings by people who seem to believe that presentation is stretching legs so far apart that jeans have to be given double stitching so they will not burst.
It has long been apparent that all the best country is coming from the independent distributors and most of who like the real thing know that without any argument.
CMA Awards….garbage in large doses.
Stormy says:
Missing from the CMA’s?
Excitement
Tim & Faith
and as much as I love Carrie Underwood- hosting is not one of her talents.
Should have been missing?
Kellie Pickler
cj says:
Has anyone thought that all these country singers that were always on the CMA’s and not on this year may have a reason. They all really had to pay there dues. These new ones if they have money they can buy there way on. They do not even have to sing good. They can have fancy props and all these dresses and make up and they are in just like that. I think all the Country Stars should stand up and be counted and not just stay home.
Greatdivide08 says:
I thought Carrie and Paisley made a great team hosting.I agree with you for once about Ashton.If that wasn’t the best new artist of the year, they should just get rid of that award altogether. Tim and Faith I could care.They’re just about the most phoniest people in country music anyway.
Toby has since blasted the CMA’S.I’m suprised you didn’t blog about that.Maybe you did and I missed it.I doubt it though, since he also took swipes at 2 of your heros Kenny Chesney and Keith Urban.
redneck girl says:
okay soo lets just poin out the obvious THE KIND OF COUNTRY WAS MISSIN GEORGE STRAIT. when you think country music you think George strait i was so disapointed not to see him sing instead we gotta whole lot of taylor swift …. um she aint country music and im tired of seein her everywhere how bout we show people who really matter
GEORGE STRAIT
GARTH BROOKS
REBA
SHINA
LUKE BRYAN
BROOKS AND DUNN
KEITH URBAN
JASON ALDEAN
and so many more true country artist get this fake pop country stuff outta here your bringin country down.